Reserve for Dummies
#4191
I get it, and you are technically correct. But you're not going to win the argument. There is no timeframe for when you have to "ascertain" if you've been converted to SC or given a rotation. If you choose to do so on your X day that is your decision. Nothing prevents you from waiting until you start LC at midnight to take whatever action you deem necesaary to ascertain if you've been given an assignment. It's definitely a grey area though, because say you're given a 1000 SC, and you ascertain this at 0600 in the morning. Well now you don't technically have 10 hours prospective rest before starting the SC period. The system is designed to assume you always become aware right at midnight.
#4192
On Reserve
Joined: Oct 2019
Posts: 153
Likes: 21
I get it, and you are technically correct. But you're not going to win the argument. There is no timeframe for when you have to "ascertain" if you've been converted to SC or given a rotation. If you choose to do so on your X day that is your decision. Nothing prevents you from waiting until you start LC at midnight to take whatever action you deem necesaary to ascertain if you've been given an assignment. It's definitely a grey area though, because say you're given a 1000 SC, and you ascertain this at 0600 in the morning. Well now you don't technically have 10 hours prospective rest before starting the SC period. The system is designed to assume you always become aware right at midnight.
Seems clear to me one has a responsibility to ascertain this at noon, otherwise it would be impossible for them to know if they are on an 18 hour leash or not and exactly what their reserve responsibilities are starting at midnight. One must know before a reserve period begins when the reserve period begins, so you need to know before midnight if you're actually on LC or not, it can't be a guessing game where you find out exactly at midnight whether you are on reserve or rest.
#4193
Roll’n Thunder
Joined: Oct 2009
Posts: 5,170
Likes: 581
From: Pilot
There is only one time that you can ascertain if something is on your schedule no later than 1200, and that's at 1200. The overall context in the PWA is talking about when CS has to call you or not, and the 2 situations are prior to your release from a rotation (when you are required to check your schedule), and 12 hours before the end of your last non-fly day. Furthermore, the SRH says for such an assignment "it is the pilot's responsibility to ascertain any such assignment. If nothing appears on a reserve pilot's schedule at that 12-hour point... blah blah".
Seems clear to me one has a responsibility to ascertain this at noon, otherwise it would be impossible for them to know if they are on an 18 hour leash or not and exactly what their reserve responsibilities are starting at midnight. One must know before a reserve period begins when the reserve period begins, so you need to know before midnight if you're actually on LC or not, it can't be a guessing game where you find out exactly at midnight whether you are on reserve or rest.
Seems clear to me one has a responsibility to ascertain this at noon, otherwise it would be impossible for them to know if they are on an 18 hour leash or not and exactly what their reserve responsibilities are starting at midnight. One must know before a reserve period begins when the reserve period begins, so you need to know before midnight if you're actually on LC or not, it can't be a guessing game where you find out exactly at midnight whether you are on reserve or rest.
Again, I’m not going to argue the technical details of not being aware of something until midnight or later. No one on this board can change anything. Your best place to start is a dart to the scheduling committee, and I guarantee they will tell you basically what I have. If you truly want to affect change then you’re going to have to take the fight to the FAA level. Don’t ascertain things until well after midnight when you then wouldn’t have 10 hours prospective rest. Start declining to report for assignments due to your perceived FAR 117 violations. File ASAPs every time. Until the FAA says this setup isn’t legal then neither the company nor the union will push to affect change.
#4194
There is only one time that you can ascertain if something is on your schedule no later than 1200, and that's at 1200. The overall context in the PWA is talking about when CS has to call you or not, and the 2 situations are prior to your release from a rotation (when you are required to check your schedule), and 12 hours before the end of your last non-fly day. Furthermore, the SRH says for such an assignment "it is the pilot's responsibility to ascertain any such assignment. If nothing appears on a reserve pilot's schedule at that 12-hour point... blah blah".
Seems clear to me one has a responsibility to ascertain this at noon, otherwise it would be impossible for them to know if they are on an 18 hour leash or not and exactly what their reserve responsibilities are starting at midnight. One must know before a reserve period begins when the reserve period begins, so you need to know before midnight if you're actually on LC or not, it can't be a guessing game where you find out exactly at midnight whether you are on reserve or rest.
Seems clear to me one has a responsibility to ascertain this at noon, otherwise it would be impossible for them to know if they are on an 18 hour leash or not and exactly what their reserve responsibilities are starting at midnight. One must know before a reserve period begins when the reserve period begins, so you need to know before midnight if you're actually on LC or not, it can't be a guessing game where you find out exactly at midnight whether you are on reserve or rest.
This is how it works. And frankly, you don't want it to work differently. Kinda like SC report time. You don't want it defined. Because then, if you scan on one minute late, you are subject to discipline. Likewise, you don't want to be forced to do a schedule check at midnight, because that's the only way around it.
You seem tone afraid you are violating the FAR's by checking your schedule. You 100% are not.
#4195
On Reserve
Joined: Oct 2019
Posts: 153
Likes: 21
But you don't have a responsibility to ascertain at noon (really, 12 hour before starting LC). That's the point. You are conflating FAR rules and PWA 'legality'. IF the company places it on your schedule before then, you can be made to report as early at 10 hours after starting LC. WHEN you make yourself aware of that is completely up to you. A commuter may have a different decision than a local, but it's ultimately irrelevant. What difference does it make to you the individual? You are perfectly welcome to wake up at midnight and check your schedule. You have that flexibility. And you don't have to determine the PWA 'legality' at/after noon. You can choose to check it, and screenshot a blank schedule as a hedge against an illegally placed assignment to fight that later, but that has nothing to do with the FAR's.
This is how it works. And frankly, you don't want it to work differently. Kinda like SC report time. You don't want it defined. Because then, if you scan on one minute late, you are subject to discipline. Likewise, you don't want to be forced to do a schedule check at midnight, because that's the only way around it.
You seem tone afraid you are violating the FAR's by checking your schedule. You 100% are not.
This is how it works. And frankly, you don't want it to work differently. Kinda like SC report time. You don't want it defined. Because then, if you scan on one minute late, you are subject to discipline. Likewise, you don't want to be forced to do a schedule check at midnight, because that's the only way around it.
You seem tone afraid you are violating the FAR's by checking your schedule. You 100% are not.
I want to believe I'm wrong on this. But nothing I've heard addresses the logic I've outlined adequately.
#4196
Roll’n Thunder
Joined: Oct 2009
Posts: 5,170
Likes: 581
From: Pilot
Ok, so we don't have an obligation to check it at noon, but we have an obligation to take an action at some point all the same. When you do that action would either be prior to midnight or after midnight. If you do it prior to midnight, it would violate your 30 hr rest. If you do it at or after, it would violate your 10 hour rest for a 10am FDP or RAP. Either way, this obligation would violate rest. You also couldn't legally start LC without knowing the LC start time beforehand, meaning really you'd have to check it prior to LC starting at midnight.
I want to believe I'm wrong on this. But nothing I've heard addresses the logic I've outlined adequately.
I want to believe I'm wrong on this. But nothing I've heard addresses the logic I've outlined adequately.
#4197
Gets Weekends Off
Joined: Jul 2013
Posts: 12,546
Likes: 1,151
Ok, so we don't have an obligation to check it at noon, but we have an obligation to take an action at some point all the same. When you do that action would either be prior to midnight or after midnight. If you do it prior to midnight, it would violate your 30 hr rest. If you do it at or after, it would violate your 10 hour rest for a 10am FDP or RAP. Either way, this obligation would violate rest. You also couldn't legally start LC without knowing the LC start time beforehand, meaning really you'd have to check it prior to LC starting at midnight.
I want to believe I'm wrong on this. But nothing I've heard addresses the logic I've outlined adequately.
I want to believe I'm wrong on this. But nothing I've heard addresses the logic I've outlined adequately.
#4198
On Reserve
Joined: Oct 2019
Posts: 153
Likes: 21
You don't have to believe. You are wrong. Checking your schedule at a time of your own choosing is not a violation of rest. It's in the LOI. There is only one required schedule check, the one after you finish an assignment. You are never required to answer the phone or acknowledge an assignment on LC and you're never required to answer the phone on short call. You trying to make an issue out of this purely so you can try and say 10am shows are illegal is to the detriment of everyone else.
#4199
However the company can require activity when you are on long call. That activity is a schedule check as soon as you begin LC.
#4200
Gets Weekends Off
Joined: Jul 2013
Posts: 12,546
Likes: 1,151
Having a requirement of any kind put on you during rest is a violation of rest. You say I'm wrong, but offer no logic of how I'm wrong. You are assuming my intentions, and doing so incorrectly. You are also assuming the only outcome would be a "detriment" to everyone else. I don't want to violate the FARs. Forcing the company to not violate the FARs would not necessarily be a detriment to anyone. Imagine if they had to contact you to notify you of those trips/SC periods, and couldn't do so unless you were contactable. That would be a great outcome for us, and we would have all the chips since the company would have to solve the problem, and we would have to agree to any solution. We would need only agree to a solution that benefitted us.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post



